TRP 354: SPECIAL EPISODE - Canary in the Coal Mine: What Weil Gotshal Can Teach Every Partner About Firm Risk with Scott Love
The Rainmaking PodcastNovember 10, 202600:16:36

TRP 354: SPECIAL EPISODE - Canary in the Coal Mine: What Weil Gotshal Can Teach Every Partner About Firm Risk with Scott Love

“A law firm is nothing more than a collective of peers held together only by conditional promises to each other.”

When a firm collapses, it doesn’t happen in seven days. The signs were there for years. The question is whether you were looking.

In this special solo episode, Scott Love, legal recruiter and host of The Rainmaking Podcast, looks at what Weil Gotshal can teach every partner about law firm risk. He’s been recruiting in legal since 2009 and has met with more than 80 law firm leaders in person. He walks through the five lenses he uses to assess a firm’s stability: financial health, leadership and governance, talent flow, reputation, and culture.

What you’ll learn:

  • Why law firms are fragile organizations, and what Dewey LeBoeuf, LeClairRyan, and Stroock taught Scott firsthand
  • Why partners leave firms for one of two reasons: strategy or leadership
  • The financial warning signs, from vendor bills pushed into Q1 to falling profits per equity partner and delayed distributions
  • The leadership and governance red flags, including missing succession plans, abrupt compensation changes, and failed mergers
  • Why departures that come in groups, from the top, with anchor clients, are the clearest talent-flow signal
  • What it means when summer classes are cut, offers are rescinded, and a firm’s own partners start calling recruiters
  • Why culture is “the last line of defense” when the numbers slip
  • Why no single warning sign means a firm is failing, and why the cluster is what matters
  • How to score your own firm with the free 30-question framework and downloadable PDF dashboard
  • When merging is the “least worst” decision, and when it’s the best opportunity

https://therainmakingmagazine.com/p/canary-in-the-coal-mine-what-weil-gotshal-can-teach-every-partner-about-firm-risk

Visit: https://therainmakingpodcast.com/

YouTube: https://youtu.be/xizz2gce7C8

---------------------------------------- If you are a successful law firm partner or law firm founder and want to hear about other options, please book a time on Scott Love's calendar here: https://attorneysearchgroup.com/schedule Or email Scott to connect with him at: scott@attorneysearchgroup.com ----------------------------------------

This podcast is sponsored by SurePoint Legal Insights (formerly known as Leopard Solutions)–turning legal intelligence into opportunity.

For a free demo, visit this link: https://surepoint.com/legal-insights/ ----------------------------------------

About Scott Love:
Scott Love is a legal recruiter solely focused on recruiting corporate and finance partners for global law firms in major markets. He is the host of The Rainmaking Podcast, co-author of Rainmaker Confidential, and speaks professionally at conferences on sales, client development, and recruiting.
🧭 Confidential quiz and strategy for partners considering a move: partnersonthemove.com
🎓 Monthly live events for transactional partners: RainmakingSeminars.com

📘 Book: Rainmaker Confidential — RainmakerConfidential.com 📖 Rainmaking Magazine: free complimentary subscription at TheRainmakingMagazine.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

[00:00:10] You're listening to The Rainmaking Podcast, hosted by legal dealmaker, author, and professional speaker, Scott Love

[00:00:25] You're listening to The Rainmaking Podcast, and my name is Scott Love. Thanks for joining me on the show. This is part of our Sometimes Tuesdays legal-specific series. Most of our episodes are evergreen, where you can listen to something two weeks ago that was published on our show five years from now, and it'll still give you the same amount of value.

[00:00:43] But today is also a special episode. We're talking about Weil Gotshal. We're talking about how that firm's collapse can be an indication of a canary in the coal mine, what Weil Gotshal can teach every partner about law firm risk. Before I go into this, let me give a shout out to our sponsors, SharePoint Legal Insights, formerly known as Leopard Solutions, turning legal intelligence into opportunity. Also, the show is sponsored by The Rainmaking Magazine, with over 40 authors and contributors

[00:01:13] sharing the best ideas in client development, absolutely free. The Rainmaking Magazine.com. Also, if you're a transactional partner for law firms and you want ideas that can help you maximize your deal flow, attend our live half-hour events over Zoom webinars once a month, the third week of the month, where I interview a different author or business development coach for lawyers each month with live Q&A. Visit RainmakingSeminars.com to get on the list, and your info won't be shared with anyone outside of our organization.

[00:01:43] Now, let me get into this. Let me give you some perspective. I've been recruiting in legal since 2009, and when I got into it, I saw that law firms are fragile organizations. I used to recruit in a different industry, which was, I wouldn't say healthier, but they had tangible assets. It was a different type of P&L. When you look at the assets of a law firm, well, you know as well as I do that those assets leave every day. At the end of the day, they walk out the door. And I will tell you this.

[00:02:11] A law firm is nothing more than a collective of peers held together only by conditional promises to each other. We've seen collapses over the years. Do you remember Dewey LaBeouf? Well, everybody thought, what's going on over there? Could it be these long guarantees? I'll never forget, if you go to YouTube and type in Bloomberg, Dewey LaBeouf, headhunters,

[00:02:36] you'll see a video where a prominent partner was interviewed by Bloomberg, and he says the collapse of Dewey LeBoeuf was because of headhunters. And that's not true. We know that somebody was cooking the books, too. I remember when LeClaire Ryan collapsed, I'd heard from multiple partners among other and different offices the same concern they had about rapid growth. My experience with Stroock was more firsthand. I had a law firm, MLAW50, chairman in conversations with Strook's chairman.

[00:03:06] They were probably about the second or third firm to talk with him, and my client, the MLAW50 chairman, declined to go forward after that conversation. And there are several other chairmen that met with Stroock over and over again, and you all know the rest of the story. Strook collapsed. And I think that their problem was that they had advertised that we're on the market. That's a signal. Everything about the legal industry is all based on optics and signaling, and people make career decisions and strategy decisions based on that.

[00:03:36] Now, let's talk about Weill Gotshal. Before I do that, my favorite television series is Mad Men. I've actually watched it four times, start to finish, the whole thing. Yes, it's that good. And Jon Hamm, the star of the show, he first gained significant notoriety in his role as Don Draper on that series. And as he put it, it took him 12 years to become an overnight success. And that same concept applies to law firms that implode.

[00:04:06] Weill did not fall apart in seven days. Issues had been brewing below the surface for years. Now, the things I'm going to share with you were not all happening within while. But there are five different categories that I've created to share with you where you can look through those lenses at your own firm and determine should you be looking at other options. I think this has given us all in the legal industry an existential wake-up call.

[00:04:35] As law firms are so fragile, what is the glue that holds them together? It's one type of glue that you probably don't hear much about. It's leadership. When I was on active duty before I got into the recruiting industry in 1995, I was third in command of a U.S. Navy ship. And then after that, I was a leadership trainer at the world's largest naval base. So I grew up studying leadership. I was an Eagle Scout. That's something I really loved learning about and seeing. And when I came to the legal industry, I saw that there was no leadership development program anywhere.

[00:05:04] Nobody really thought about that until people started departing. And now you might see some of that, but it has a long way to go. From my experience in having met with over 80 law firm leaders in person, not to mention probably about 2,000 more Zoom calls with people in different firms. Law firms leave, or law firm partners leave for one of two reasons. It can be in either of these two buckets, strategy issues and leadership issues. Sometimes those combine.

[00:05:32] I've talked to probably about 1,000 partners every year in getting to know what motivates them. In terms of their career success, their options. And so I hear a lot of street intel about which firms are doing well and which are not. So I'm putting this all together in a format, in a construct for you. You can go to the Rainmaking Magazine and read the whole article absolutely free. Just register for it. Your info is not shared with anybody outside of our organization.

[00:05:57] The whole thing is there, as well as a framework, a dashboard that you can download in PDF form. So you can see how your firm compares with all the other firms out there on the 30 different areas that I'm talking about today. Now, there's five different categories. There's financial health. There's leadership and governance. There's talent flow. And also reputation. And then finally, culture. And like I mentioned, Wyle didn't fit all of these.

[00:06:25] But all of these are things I think you need to look at for your firm today. Let's talk about financial health. Here's an interesting question that might actually shock you to know that large global law firms do this. Has your firm stopped paying vendor bills due in fourth quarter and push them till first quarter just to make the year-end numbers look better? Yes, this happens. Is your profit per partner equity metric falling?

[00:06:53] Well, firms that you would consider peer firms, their metric is rising. And I've got my whole opinion on what that is and the good and bad of profits per equity partner. But that's a metric that people look at to determine health. How is yours doing with everybody else? Have partner distributions been delayed or have capital contributions gone up? Is the firm de-equitizing partners or is it quietly growing the non-equity tier?

[00:07:20] Is revenue concentrated in one practice or a handful of rainmakers? Have you seen realizations in collections slipping with the frantic push to collect at year ends? Let's talk about your firm's growth. Are they closing offices? Are they subleasing space? Or has your firm opened offices in several new markets that are not considered major markets in quick succession without a clear strategy tying that expansion to its established partners?

[00:07:50] Partners, I understand if you have a tech practice, you should open up an office in the Bay Area in California. That makes sense. But why would you do things that just don't make sense over and over again? Also, have you seen business development and marketing budgets being cut within your firm? The next category is leadership and governance. Is there a succession plan in place in your firm? Are there consistently bad management decisions?

[00:08:15] Have you seen multiple C-level staff turn over without staying very long? Has the chair stepped down suddenly? Or was there a contested leadership election? I've seen firms that have had this happen seven or eight years ago and they're still dealing with the consequences of that. Has the compensation system changed abruptly? Has a publicized merger failed?

[00:08:42] Sometimes collapsed talk often means a firm is shopping for a rescue. But other times, they can be the reason for a firm to make changes and survive and in fact grow because of that. It all has to be looked at with context. Another indication which is significant is talent flow. And you've seen it while the departures came in groups and they came from the top. And if you go to the headlines, you can read the sequence of that. But questions you should ask about your own firm.

[00:09:12] Have you seen large groups leave over short periods of time? Are departing partners taking anchor clients with them? I've seen this in smaller firms where back after COVID, there was a peak in demand. So big firms relax their requirements. They're picking off associates from smaller firms. The partners in smaller firms said, I'm not doing associate work. I'm taking my clients and going somewhere else.

[00:09:36] And then small firm founders had real bad problems and tough decisions to make. Are more partners leaving than arriving laterally over an 18 to 24 month window? Now, one thing about that, the numbers can look good. Oh, we're increasing the headcount. We're up 3%. But the people that they brought on board came out of government or they came out of in-house. They didn't bring a book with them. There are some firms where they do a fantastic job of recruiting people that don't have any clients.

[00:10:06] They moved to their firm. And those are the only press releases that you see. There's no large groups joining from significant peer-level firms. And that's just a bad trend. It's the firm paying large guarantees to replace the talent it's losing. Now, you're probably thinking of Dewey LeBoeuf because that was one of the stories that we heard about years ago. In fact, I remember talking with several Dewey partners and kind of hearing that there are some issues over there before it became public.

[00:10:34] And one thing I'll never forget is going to YouTube. And you can go to YouTube and you can type in Bloomberg Dewey Leboeuf headhunters. And you can see a video where there's a prominent partner being interviewed saying that the headhunters were the reason Dewey Leboeuf fell apart. Now, I think they're the people that pulled people out. But as we all know, there was more to the story in terms of financial irregularities, people cooking the books. Sometimes you have to look at that, the whole picture as well.

[00:11:02] Also, is your firm a top-tier firm that is not paying the Cravath scale? How important are high-quality associates to your firm? This is something I hear from a lot of firms. And it's not necessarily the Cravath scale. It's just they're not bringing anybody on board that can do the work. Have summer classes been cut? Summer programs? Have start dates been deferred? Have offers been rescinded? Are the firm's own partners reaching out to recruiters?

[00:11:28] When the inbound calls from one firm spike, the market usually learns why six months later. The next area is reputation. Within your own firm, has there been negative press about ethics or malpractice? And has there been a series of incidents reported in the news over and over with your firm? What about negative press about sexual harassment?

[00:11:55] Have tranches of staff been let go with minimal severance? Also, is there a pattern of allegations, even if it's not proven? But are there allegations of multiple lawsuits or complaints? Even female attorneys, sadly, not getting paid equal pay. I think Reddit is an interesting source for unvarnished information. Now, of course, there's no accountability. It's just words anonymously posted on a website.

[00:12:24] But when you see certain patterns of your own firm being talked about in Reddit, you should pay attention to that. Culture. This is the last line of defense. When the numbers slip, partners who trust each other stay and fight. Like I mentioned, it comes down to leadership. A law firm is nothing more than a collective of peers held together only by conditional promises to each other. And that's it.

[00:12:50] But those firms where there is trust, I have seen some firms, some firms I know very well, they had a series of decline. Nothing salacious, no lawsuits, just people left. And some of them decided to stay independent and fight their way through it. And they did. Others made the correct decision to form a combination with another firm. And sometimes in those areas, I've had lots of discussions with law firm founders. Some have decided to stay independent. Others have said, okay, I'll take a look.

[00:13:19] Sometimes it's not an issue of what's the best decision, but what's the least worst decision. Sometimes merging is the best opportunity. You have to give up certain things like control and a brand. But it gives your clients support. It gives yourself and your partners and also the people behind you in their career, the associates, opportunities to grow. But questions you should look for in terms of culture. Are there complaints about associate support? Is the morale poor?

[00:13:49] Are partners fighting over origination credit and hoarding clients instead of cross-selling? When you see this happen, partners know. I'm not going to bring new clients in that I have to share so it does not build a healthy firm. Now, no single answer on this list means a firm is failing. Every firm loses partners. They miss a year or they face a lawsuit that happens to every law firm. What matters is the cluster. Weill showed signs in all five areas at once.

[00:14:19] Slow relative growth, a broken succession, group departures, reputational damage from past cuts, and a culture where people stopped betting on each other. All of that converged into a negative event. So I'd recommend score your own firm honestly. Now, you can get this program in an article format on therainmakingmagazine.com. In fact, if you go to the show notes, I put the link that takes you to this article.

[00:14:49] It's absolutely free. You have to register. But like I said, I'm not sharing your info with anybody else. And that's there for you for free. And also, in addition to that, is the dashboard in a PDF format that you can download. Take it. Print it out. Journal on it. Go through all the 30 different questions that I give you and assess how your firm is doing. I'm always open to talking to people even if they don't want to move. I'll talk to anybody. I'll talk to counsel. I'll talk to partners without a book.

[00:15:18] And if I can't help them, I know a lot of friendly competitors. I'm always happy to make appropriate referrals. And if you decide to stay with your firm, that's totally fine. Another resource you may want to check out if it is time for you to move is go to this link, partnersonthemove.com. I lay out an entire strategy for a partner moving. If you DIY, you don't have to type in your info. If you're just not sure about staying with your firm, go to partnersonthemove.com.

[00:15:44] There's a confidential quiz that you can take without entering in any data to help you assess what your next step is. I appreciate your listening to this. I hope that you find success and you can find a firm where canaries are singing very loudly. Thanks for listening. I'll see you next time. Thank you for listening to The Rainmaking Podcast.

[00:16:08] For more information about our recruiting services for international law firms, visit our website at attorneysearchgroup.com. To inquire about having Scott speak at your next convention, conference, sales meeting, or executive retreat, visit therainmakingpodcast.com. Thank you.


Produced by The Attorney Search Group

1300 I Street NW, Suite 400 East, Washington, DC 20005

(202) 391-0460

Copyright © 2023 The Rainmaking Podcast - All Rights Reserved.