TRP 353: The Psychology of Pricing: Why Professional Services Firms Underprice and How to Fix It with Etinosa Agbonlahor
The Rainmaking PodcastNovember 05, 202600:26:31

TRP 353: The Psychology of Pricing: Why Professional Services Firms Underprice and How to Fix It with Etinosa Agbonlahor

Would you pay $20 for an umbrella? What about $100 on your way to your most important client meeting? Same umbrella, different context, and that is the psychology of pricing.

Etinosa Agbonlahor is a behavioral economist and CEO of Decision Alpha, a behavioral pricing firm that helps businesses improve pricing for growth, traction, and stronger perceived value. In this first-ever pricing episode on the Rainmaking Podcast, she joins Scott Love to explain why most professional services leaders set their rates by guessing, and what to do instead.

What you’ll learn:

  • Why context changes what clients are willing to pay, and what the umbrella test reveals about your own pricing
  • The four building blocks of a price: cost floor, willingness-to-pay ceiling, alternatives, and price framing
  • How to map “monetization zones” and research what different client groups will actually pay
  • Why your real competitor may be ChatGPT, not the firm down the street
  • The three dimensions of value (functional, emotional, and aspirational) and how reputation and cachet fit in
  • Why every proposal should include at least two options
  • What to do if you’re priced near the bottom but don’t want to signal lower quality
  • How the fear of rejection quietly drives underpricing
  • A case study: how a solo law firm used fixed fees and a subscription plan to grow revenue beyond her own billable hours and smooth out a summer slump
  • The spotlight effect: why your clients aren’t watching your rates with a magnifying glass
  • 3 action steps to evaluate and change your pricing with confidence

Visit: https://therainmakingpodcast.com/

YouTube: https://youtu.be/kgarRTU1IjE

---------------------------------------- If you are a successful law firm partner or law firm founder and want to hear about other options, please book a time on Scott Love's calendar here: https://attorneysearchgroup.com/schedule Or email Scott to connect with him at: scott@attorneysearchgroup.com

📅 Monthly webinars for transactional partners: RainmakingSeminars.com ----------------------------------------

This podcast is sponsored by SurePoint Legal Insights (formerly known as Leopard Solutions)–turning legal intelligence into opportunity.

For a free demo, visit this link: https://surepoint.com/legal-insights/ ----------------------------------------

About Etinosa Agbonlahor:
Etinosa Agbonlahor is a behavioral economist and CEO of Decision Alpha, a behavioral pricing firm that helps businesses improve pricing for growth, traction, and stronger perceived value. With over a decade of global experience across the U.S., Australia, Africa, and the U.K., she has shaped pricing, engagement, and customer-behavior strategy for major financial institutions and venture-backed startups. Her work has been featured in MarketWatch, Morningstar, and other leading platforms for her insights on how behavior drives financial outcomes. She is also the author of How to Talk to Your Parents About Money, a guide to navigating complex financial conversations.


Links:

playbook.decisionalpha.co

fred.decisionalpha.co

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

[00:00:10] You're listening to The Rainmaking Podcast, hosted by legal dealmaker, author and professional speaker, Scott Love.

[00:00:25] You're listening to The Rainmaking Podcast, and my name is Scott Love. Thank you for being here. Today, we are talking about the psychology of pricing and underpricing. And our special guest is expert Etinosa Agbonlahor. Etinosa is a behavioral economist and CEO of Decision Alpha.

[00:00:43] It's a behavioral firm that helps businesses and professional services firms understand what customers and clients value and turn that into clearer pricing and growth. She's passionate about helping professionals reduce financial stress and live healthier financial lives. She brings over a decade of experience working across the U.S., Australia, Africa, and the United Kingdom.

[00:01:05] As always, this podcast is sponsored by SurePoint Legal Insights, turning legal intelligence into opportunity. The show is also sponsored by The Rainmaking Magazine, with over 40 authors and contributors sharing the best ideas in client development absolutely free. Visit therainmakingmagazine.com. Also, if you're a transactional partner for law firms, you do corporate finance, real estate, and you want ideas that can help you maximize your deal flow, attend our new

[00:02:03] live events. And if you get some great ideas for the show notes and you want to get some great ideas from my conversation with Etinosa, she brings a sophisticated perspective on pricing, which may challenge what you've thought about this. Check out all of her information on the show notes and connect with her today. Thanks so much for listening. And now here's my conversation with Etinosa.

[00:02:21] Hey, this is Scott Love with The Rainmaking Podcast. Our special guest today is Etinosa Agbonlahor. And today we're talking about the psychology of pricing and underpricing. Etinosa, thank you so much for joining me on the show today. Thank you for having me, Scott. I'm looking forward to the conversation. Absolutely. And we have never had this topic on our show, so it's about time. So I appreciate having someone like you with your specialized expertise to talk about this.

[00:02:46] And let me ask you this. When we talk about the psychology of pricing, what does that mean and why is that important for professionals that are in the professional services businesses? That's a great question. And I often start by saying when we think about how people buy things, we often assume that people buy things, you know, they look at the number and then they decide to go from there.

[00:03:07] But there's a whole lot more to it. So let me give you an anecdote. Let's say you are. What would you pay for an umbrella? And this is a real question. So what would you pay for an umbrella? It depends on whether it's raining or not. And so I'd say on average, 20 bucks. I'd be willing to spend 20 bucks on an umbrella. So let's say now you're in New York, you're heading to a meeting, you have to walk over to the meeting on food because it's New York.

[00:03:32] Starts downpouring out of nowhere and somebody magically appears on the corner. And this actually happens in New York every time it rains. Somebody magically appears on the corner selling umbrellas. Now, what is the maximum you're willing to pay for an umbrella that you need to get to your next meeting? Depends on how important that client is. I'm on my way to see. But I'd say 50 to 100 now. There you go. Right. And so that is the psychology of pricing in action. It's the same umbrella. It serves the same function, but the context has changed how you value it. Right.

[00:04:02] Just based on the context, it's almost doubled your willingness to pay for the exact same thing. And so that in a nutshell explains the psychology of pricing is the fact that the way people interact with numbers, the way we make financial decisions is skewed based on the environment and the context in which we're interacting. And so that can drive your customers to choose a price, choose to work with you, go look for other research, go look for other prices. It can drive people to choose a smaller package versus a bigger one. It influences and informs choice.

[00:04:30] And so the psychology of pricing is how do we design our pricing and structure it in a way that's going to get customers who want to work with us and who choose the packages, the services that we offer in the way that we want them to. That is it in a nutshell. So what do you think are the main attributes or variables or data that decision makers need to look at to determine what the pricing is? You mentioned it's the context. Where should they be looking for that context?

[00:04:56] Yeah, I talk about pricing as we have what we call a price in-house at Decision Alpha, and that's made up of a couple of things. First, you have your cost floor, which is what does it cost to keep the lights on in the business and what does it cost to deliver your service, right? We very rarely deliver services that are completely free. There's some costs, your employee costs, your, you know, whatever technology costs, there's costs associated in that, right? So there's what we call a cost floor. What does it cost to keep the lights on and to deliver this service?

[00:05:24] There's also what we call the willingness to pay ceiling, which is what is the maximum anybody out there is willing to pay for your services? That is the max, right? So you've got the floor, you've got the max. In between are the pillars of your competitors, your alternatives. And when I talk about alternatives, a lot of times we think that our real competition is the other lawyer down the street from us, when sometimes your real competition is the fact that your client is trying to bootstrap legal advice and charge GPT, right?

[00:05:50] They look at that as a replacement for your services when it shouldn't be. But we think about competitors, we think about alternatives, and the last pillar in that pricing structure is what we call the price framing. How do you set up your price that's going to sway customers one way or another? Do you do a subscription? Do you use round numbers? Do you offer two or three options versus one? There's a reason to do those things in different contexts. All of that together is what makes the pricing house and what builds really good pricing. That's great.

[00:06:18] And so what about customer input or customer, if we could read minds and find out what is that customer willing to pay and how can we maximize that in a way that gives them more value than what they're paying for? How do you think we can get that information? The way that we get to that information when clients come to us. So, for example, we worked with a big nonprofit, 20 million in revenue, built a new platform to solve a problem within their ecosystem, came to us and said, A, this is so niche.

[00:06:48] We don't want to sell it to everybody. But B, how do we even price this thing? There's nothing like it out there. We built it to solve a problem we're experiencing in our ecosystem. And so we needed to understand, well, what are other people willing to pay for this? Right. And so the first thing that we did was we do this exercise. We call it mapping monetization zones. What we're essentially trying to understand is there's going to be different types of people who buy from you. Right.

[00:07:12] An enterprise buyer looks very different to a small business buyer, which looks very different to like a hobbyist down the block. Right. Very different types of clients you might be appealing to. We know that we might be able to charge and indeed we probably will charge them differently, even though the product at its core is the same. Service at the core is the same. Now, we break that up. We have the different kind of customer groups, your ICPs, if you will. We move them into the next step, which is where we actually, to your question, do the pricing research.

[00:07:41] Right. And in the pricing research, we're trying to understand how do you value this? Right. We know the problem is trying to solve for you. How are you solving the problem today? Hey, what is it costing to solve that problem today? What solutions have you looked at? What competitors have you looked at? How do they charge you? What are you paying for that? Now, looking at the different elements of value that you've identified in this product or service, what is your willingness to pay for it? What is too high that you would never consider? What's too cheap that would make you go there's something there has to be something wrong with it? What are the in-betweens?

[00:08:11] What's expensive for you? Consider it, et cetera, et cetera. Right. So we're doing research like that to try and extrapolate from the different potential prospects, the different ICPs. What are you willing to pay for this? How do you value this? We want to get a number and a range. Once we have that range across the different segments, then we take it into how do you actually frame the price? Do you offer options? What tiers do you offer? Do you do it hourly? Do you include onboarding costs, et cetera?

[00:08:37] Once we framed it, we do the last step, which is what we call the test and iteration step, meaning that we set a price one time, but we don't believe that that is the only time you should ever look at your price. We think that pricing should be a feature and not a reaction, which means that every so often you go back and you say, am I delivering more value? Are we interacting more with clients? Are we doing the work faster, better? Have we grown the team? What new value are we delivering and how do we make sure price is reflective of that?

[00:09:03] It doesn't mean that you're going to change your price every single time you do this exercise, but it does mean you have your finger on the pulse of what's changing, what value are we delivering and why. And so for that big company that we worked with, what we ended up doing in addition to just pricing ranges for them was also helping them understand that even though they initially wanted to sell to a vast range of different types of companies within their ecosystem,

[00:09:27] we, through our research, realized that companies are actually more mature and have a more mature tech stack, understood the impact and the purpose of the tool that had built immediately. It was like light bulb, like, oh, this is incredible. This is going to solve so many problems for us. This is going to help with revenue issues we've been having. Like they got it, right? Other companies that were smaller and maybe less mature in their tech infrastructure were like, maybe we hook it up to the website.

[00:09:54] We're not so sure. It feels like a solution within our problem. We don't really know. And so we could go back to our client and say, not only is this the range you should be looking for in terms of what you charge, but this is the right group to go after initially because you're going to be able to sell to them faster, better, easier, get the revenue in the door before you can then, you know, spend a year or two doing that. And then a year or two, maybe we sit down and we look at how do we go after the smaller clients. So end to end, that's kind of what it looks like to do that research and bring it all together.

[00:10:22] Okay, great. I appreciate that. That sounds like a robust strategy with a lot of depth. And I appreciate you sharing that, Etiosa. Let me ask you this. What about reputation and cachet? Let's say there's an offer that has leaned on a very good reputation and they can charge a little bit more just because they have that cachet. They've got a long list of clients that they can show. How do you think that impacts pricing?

[00:10:47] So it's very interesting because yesterday I was talking to another lawyer about price elasticity, which is that you have done, you offer the same thing, but you're somehow able to charge different things along that curve for the same thing that you offer. Now, what reputation and cachet, how they play a role in all of this is what I call differentiation. As human beings, we like to make comparisons to other things. That's fundamental to human nature. It's very hard for us to judge something in a vacuum. And I'll give you a point. I'll give you a little tidbit about that.

[00:11:16] It's why when you send proposals to clients, you should have at least two options on that proposal because they need something to compare it to. If you don't send options in your proposal, they're going to compare you to other competitors. You will lose out on business. But coming back to the question asked, because we like to make comparisons to other things to make them make sense to us, to understand their value, when you don't have that reputation, that cachet, when people look at you and they think you do the same thing that every kind of term they can carry on the block does, it becomes easy for them to compare it to them.

[00:11:46] They're looking at their value and looking at it as if it's the same thing. Whereas when you have that reputation, that cachet, you almost have a way of differentiating yourself. When we talk about value, we often as professionals think about it in one dimension, right? I, you know, I create estate plans. That's what I do. That's the value I offer people. Actually, value has three dimensions at least. There's the functional value, which is the I create estate plans. That's what I do for people. There's also the emotional value.

[00:12:13] Because you created an estate plan for me, I feel that my family is well taken care of. That's just an emotional connection there, right? I feel safety. I feel peace of mind. I'm no longer anxious about what's going to happen to my estate. I know because you have helped me work on it. There's an emotional value there. There's also then that aspirational value. And that goes to your point about reputation and cachet. So people might choose to, I work with this firm because they are the best in the city. And I want to be able to tell my clients that they are the lawyers I work with. I have a friend who's a lawyer.

[00:12:42] She works with a CPA very specifically because she likes their brand. And she wanted to, you know, she could have gone to anybody else, but she's like, I like their brand. I want to work with them, right? So that aspirational value and aspirational nature of it as well is another element of value that we sometimes don't consider. But those three elements of value can all come together and then inform and influence why people choose to work with you, how they value you, and what they're willing to pay for your services. Right. That's great. I like that.

[00:13:09] And I think a lot of firms, professional services firms and law firms especially, some of them have not yet really identified those variables and how they determine what their pricing is. I have some clients that in the spectrum of where they charge, it's called fee flexibility or rate flexibility. But they don't want to start off with we're lower than our competitors.

[00:13:29] How do you think organizations like that can really sell themselves where they know they're not at the top of the chart in terms of cost, but they're kind of on the lower end, but they don't want it to seem like the quality is less. How do you think they should convey that to their clients at Yosa? Well, there's a couple of different things, right? The real question, it feels like you're asking here, is how do they get creative in how they talk about and display and demonstrate their pricing, right?

[00:13:56] Because it sounds like we are low enough that we have a worry about being seen as too low, but we're not yet, you know, we're not touching. We're not the cheapest, but we also don't want to be seen as the cheapest. And in that instance, there's where you have flexibility with how you show and display your pricing, right? For example, if everyone around you is doing a billable hour, maybe there are matters where you can talk to and point to, we do this on a fixed fee because we want to give you a mental guarantee, right?

[00:14:23] Maybe everyone else is doing a billable hour and it's quite, or maybe everyone is doing fixed fees very low. You say, we'd have a fixed fee, but these are the contingencies that we add to it, right? If you think about how can we get creative and add a guarantee or kind of make the customer feel more comfortable with the number I'm putting in front of them. I also think that if you're looking at your numbers and you think we're close to the bottom, but we're not quite the bottom, then there should be a question there, rightly so, about quality, right?

[00:14:51] If everyone else is charged way more than us to deliver the same amount of work, do we have leeway here? Is there a strategic reason for us to be priced the way we are, right? Is there a strategic reason for us to be priced where we are? Are we here just because we're kind of at the bottom, we're scared to do the research, we're worried that if we raise our rates, everyone is going to flip the table and walk away from us? So I would actually question that, you know, we're low, we want to get creative with how we show our price,

[00:15:17] we have this rate flexibility, but we're hovering at the bottom and we're low enough that people are worried about quality. I would actually want to dig deeper into and see, well, should you be that low? Do we need to talk about that? Do we need to lean into that and figure out what's going on there? Yeah, that's right. Are there things that they can do to test certain price offerings with clients? What do you think about that? Yeah, absolutely. There's no reason you couldn't, when prospects come in, put a new price in front of them and see how they react to it, right?

[00:15:45] I think that sometimes because as service professionals, we have this fear of rejection. And part of it is, of course, we have to make the numbers, right? You have to pay your mortgage somehow. But there's also underlying that outside of, you know, the financial element to it. There's an underlying fear of rejection. It doesn't really, you know, as human beings, we would rather just get the yes. We just want the yes. Rejection has a sting. And when you're a service professional, where what you sell is different to, you know, it's not like you're selling a pen. You're selling your services.

[00:16:15] You're selling your ingenuity. You're selling your know-how and your expertise. Sometimes somebody selling you no feels like an affront, right? It's like they've attacked you personally when that's not necessarily the case, right? And no, it's kind of like driving us towards pricing that doesn't quite, you know, doesn't quite hold the SNF test or hold up to the SNF test. That's something that we also then have to dig deeper and kind of explore. Yeah, interesting.

[00:16:43] So tell me about a professional services organization that you worked with where they went through the whole cycle of evaluating their pricing. They did the data. They did the research. What were some of the key concepts that they leaned on when making these changes? And how did it work out? You don't have to tell us who it is, of course, but tell us a story. What action steps did you advise them to do and what did they take in terms of steps to get to the results that they wanted?

[00:17:08] Yeah, we worked with a client, a firm, law firm, actually, that came to us with kind of two goals and it became three. The first one was it was run by it was a solo practitioner run, but they were expanding rapidly and she was starting to hire new people. And yet it somehow felt like most the bulk of the business still ran through her and needed her to be physically there to like get the, you know, to earn money.

[00:17:34] So she was trying to find a way to, I want the revenue to grow the business and hire more lawyers who can continue to take on better matters. I don't want that to be tied to me. What can we do in terms of separation of revenue? That was one. There was also an issue of I set my rates by guessing. So I don't actually know if I'm charging the right thing. We're a profitable business, but should we be more profitable? I'm not quite sure. How do we do that research?

[00:17:59] And then there was a third factor that kind of emerged when we were having those conversations around not only is, you know, there's the revenue and flexibility. They were not quite sure. You know, we set our prices as kind of a finger in the air. But in the summer months, we have noticed that there's a lower footfall. We kind of have less revenue coming in in the summer months than in the rest of the year. And of course, we think that's because folks are on vacation. But what can we do about that? Right.

[00:18:27] So the first thing that we did is that we started by looking at the services that they offered and really identifying which ones could be standardized and sold for a fixed fee. Because what we wanted to do was give her a way to actually grow revenue without necessarily increasing her own billable hours. So we were able to like, OK, this is what we need to do to be able to standardize some of that work. The other thing that we were able to then do was think about, is there a subscription plan here?

[00:18:51] Is there something that you could offer where for every client who comes with you, you successfully completed an issue or matter with them? Can you put this option to have a subscription plan with you? Meaning they have access to you, you know, maybe once a month, once a quarter for X, Y, Z amount of time. Maybe there's a discount on issues when they do come up. Maybe there's something else that you offer. But some sort of like very, you know, not deeply expensive. This is a firm that worked with businesses.

[00:19:17] So it wasn't, you know, we're talking like tremendous amounts of money, but something that business owners would be able to afford and wouldn't really think twice about paying you every single month to have access to your expertise as and when they needed it. So kind of formalize that, ensure that that creation and that kind of subscription was being put in front of every single client at the end of every matter consistently. Don't just do it once and don't, you know, never talk about it again. Consistently. Part of the rhythms of the law firm.

[00:19:45] You have to offer them this ability to lean into the subscription. And that subscription ended up being what also helped them kind of level off the revenue in the summer months and that full fall in the summer months because then they had more money coming in in the summer compared to the year before when they had noticed that drop off. And so that's an example of us working with the firm, not just in terms of let's change your price and let's standardize it and let's understand who's coming to you for what and kind of normalize that.

[00:20:14] But also, more importantly, looking at the firm and understanding what can we do with your revenue in a way that's going to allow you to have freedom within the business while still continuing to generate income in new and interesting ways for the firm. Well, that's great. That's truly innovative. Good job on that. What do you think the most common pitfalls and mistakes that professional services leaders make when they're going through pricing changes?

[00:20:41] The biggest one is what is discounting, preemptively discounting. And sales teams are like, you know, guilty of this as well. But outside of that, because I think we're familiar with the conversation around discounting. But outside of that, in behavioral economics, we have what we call the spotlight effect. And the spotlight effect is basically this notion that people are kind of walking around with a magnifying glass waiting for you to change something and then that's it. They're going to revolt.

[00:21:11] But the research has found out that a lot of times the average person is actually not paying too deep of attention to pricing. Your clients are not walking around with a magnifying glass waiting for you to change your billable from $300 to $350. And then that's it. They're going to flip the table. They're going to walk away because they were only with you because you were the cheapest. That's not how it works. Right.

[00:21:32] So sometimes one of the biggest pitfalls I see with pricing is that we have this conservative nature because we think if we change it too dramatically, if we change it even by 10%, that's it. Going to lose business. It's going to be churned. Not always the case. Sometimes we sit down with clients and we map out, right, you make this change. You make this increase. If X percent of people let, you would still have even more profit coming in, except now it's more money coming in. You don't have to deal with that many people.

[00:21:59] There's actually a kind of a win here if we optimize and do this thing the right way. I think that's one of the things I see with people making pricing decisions. But the biggest pitfall of them all is making decisions in isolation of the customer. So making pricing changes without having had a conversation with a prospective customer to understand how do they value you? What are they willing to pay for your services? If they weren't using you, who else would they be using? What alternatives do they consider?

[00:22:27] Because that might help you move your perspective from price here because, you know, my cost is this, I might be able to this, to, oh, there's so much margin. They would pay that much for my services. Maybe I can move up a little bit more now. That's great. This is unique. We've never had this as a topic before. So thank you for bringing your specialized expertise to us today.

[00:22:52] And if we could give our listeners three action steps that they can take to go through, to evaluate and make changes to their pricing, what do you think those three action steps would be? The three things I would recommend, Scott. First one is talk to customers, right? Just start that conversation. It doesn't have to be a formal pricing engagement. It can be very straightforward. You know, you've been working with us for a while now. What do you like about us? You know, what elements do we offer that we value, that you value?

[00:23:19] Just have that conversation and start to get a sense of how do clients actually value you. That's a good basis. Second one is it's always helpful to not only review, you know, the fixed costs, but I think that a lot of times when we run into, especially professional services, they know what it costs to keep the lights on. This is what insurance costs, et cetera. They may not have a clear sense of what it costs to deliver their service. So employee costs, the tech costs, et cetera.

[00:23:49] It's helpful to know for every kind of service you offer, what does it cost you to actually deliver that service? What that helps you do is avoid doing the discounting thing we talked about. Avoid you giving discounts that are so deep or, you know, taking on matters and not sizing them the right way and leading you to a place where you're actually in the red or making such a lean profit you may as well not have taken on the issue in the first place. So that cost exercise is very important. The third one is we tell people we have an interactive pricing guide.

[00:24:18] You can pay whatever you want for it. But when you start thinking about making changes to your pricing, you can go into that. You can, it will ask you questions and help you stress as you're thinking around the price changes you're considering and just highlight where, okay, maybe you're not thinking about competitors strongly enough. Maybe you actually shouldn't make that change and, you know, hold on until you have a better and a stronger customer base. It can give you some of that guideline. So you can also use that once you've done these first two steps to stress as your thinking as well. That's great. Well, thank you for that.

[00:24:46] And we're going to put all of your contact info on the show notes. Everybody listening today, go ahead and go to the show notes. You'll be able to connect with Etiosa directly. And tell us more about your company, about what you do, what you have that you'd like our listeners to know. Yes, absolutely. So my company's decision offer, we are a pricing strategy and consumer financial research firm. So usually we are working with companies that are building or launching new products, new services, and want to understand how do they price them?

[00:25:16] How do they position them well in the market? My team is a team of behavioral economists, which means they are all trained in how to do the research around how people make financial decisions. We do that research for you and we help you launch with a price that's not just like the cheapest or, you know, the one that like undercuts your market by 10%, but actually is the right price for the people you're trying to go after. And more importantly, allows you to identify who's the best kind of customer, who's the best ICP for the pricing range you want. Well, Etiosa, like I mentioned to everybody, visit the show notes.

[00:25:46] You'll be able to get contact with all of her contact information directly. Thanks so much for being on the show today. I really appreciate you sharing your expertise with us. Thank you for having me, Scott. I enjoyed the conversation. Thank you for listening to the Rainmaking Podcast. For more information about our recruiting services for international law firms, visit our website at attorneysearchgroup.com.

[00:26:11] To inquire about having Scott speak at your next convention, conference, sales meeting, or executive retreat, visit therainmakingpodcast.com.


Produced by The Attorney Search Group

1300 I Street NW, Suite 400 East, Washington, DC 20005

(202) 391-0460

Copyright © 2023 The Rainmaking Podcast - All Rights Reserved.